Formula
Vest value = shares × price at vest (taxed as ordinary wages)Withheld = 22% × supplemental wages up to $1M + 37% × the excessActual tax = tax(other income + vest − deduction) − tax(other income − deduction)Shortfall = actual tax − withheld (federal + state) How it works
When restricted stock units vest, the full market value of the shares becomes ordinary income, exactly like a cash bonus. Your employer must withhold tax, usually by selling some of the shares ("sell to cover") or keeping back shares ("net settlement").
For federal income tax, most employers use the flat supplemental-wage rate: 22% on supplemental pay up to $1 million in the calendar year and 37% on anything above that. The problem is that 22% is often lower than the tax you really owe. If your salary already puts you in the 24%, 32% or 35% bracket, every vested dollar is taxed at that higher rate when you file, and the gap shows up as a balance due in April.
This calculator estimates the true federal tax caused by the vest by computing your 2026 tax with and without it, using the standard deduction for your filing status, and compares that with the 22%/37% withholding. State tax is estimated with a flat rate you enter. It is an estimate, not tax advice: it ignores itemized deductions, credits, other investment income and the Additional Medicare Tax true-up.
Social Security and Medicare are also withheld on RSU income. Social Security stops once your total wages for the year reach the annual wage base, which is why late-year vests for high earners often have less taken out. These payroll taxes are usually withheld correctly, so they are shown but not counted in the shortfall.
Frequently asked questions
Do I pay tax again when I sell the shares?
Only on the change in value after vesting. Your cost basis is the price at vest. If you sell right away there is little or no extra gain; if you hold, the later gain or loss is a capital gain — long-term if held more than a year after vesting.
Can I ask my employer to withhold more?
Some employers let you choose a higher supplemental rate for RSUs. If not, you can raise withholding on your regular paycheck through your W-4, or make quarterly estimated tax payments.
Will I get a penalty for under-withholding?
You generally avoid the federal underpayment penalty if withholding and estimated payments cover at least 90% of this year's tax or 100% of last year's (110% if your prior-year AGI was over $150,000). Large vests can break that, so plan ahead.